top of page
Mamma Mia's article in Seymour South Knoxville Herald


Review from Customer - Colleen Brackins

Love this place! Every dish we've ever had tasted great, the portions are huge, and the staff is friendly. We will keep coming back. - B Oiler

Best Italian food around. I have truly loved any dish I have tried. Awesome pizza! Owners and staff are all very friendly. Definitely my family's favorite restaurant.- S Rinehart 

We have enjoyed having Mamma Mia’s in the neighborhood! The food is very good and portions are big! Friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere! Fast service for take-out food! Alfredo is tasty! Garlic knots are large! The strawberry shortcake is amazing...and huge! I encourage you to give it a try!!! - H Sentell

I've been there. Three times since they opened! Great food! Also, the servers are very friendly and great service!!! Love it!! So glad you opened!! - D Bell

We have never had a bad meal here. Pauly and Nick, yes, we are on a first name basis as I have been there so often, run a great business. The lasagna and margarita pizza are to die for. The garlic knots also make the meal and they keep them coming. Best place to eat in Seymour.  - Kevin O

Fantastic Italian food, including veal and seafood dishes. The greatest calamari in Sevier County. Family owned and operated, adds to the coziness. Huge portions, also. A must try! - Taraizor10

Excellent. Fresh. Delicious marinara sauce that I ate with a spoon. Nice small portion of lasagna for lunch complete with salad and garlic knots. Took a traditional cannoli home for later. Calzone was enormous enough for three good eaters. We will visit soon. - 949daryln

Terry Evanswood.jpg
Red Hat Club.jpg

The wonderful Ladies of the Red Hat Club

enjoying lunch in our private dining room.

Scott and Rhonda Self.jpg

We love our Pathways family!  Thanks for stopping in Rhonda and Scott!

We just ordered take out from here for the first time. I can't believe we haven't tried this place before! The food is absolutely AMAZING! I ordered the Mama Mia's Trio so that we could try some of a few different things and my husband is a burger guy, so he got the Smokehouse Burger. Everything was cooked to perfection and tasted great and the portions were huge. We will definitely be back for sure!   - Brittany B


Our new sign is up!

Ordered take out yesterday evening. Definitely was some one of the best Pizza's I've ever had! had the Deluxe and Barbecue Chicken Pizza and also got some breaded zucchini which was one of the best appetizers I've ever had. Portions were huge and everything was hot and made to order. The girl that took my order and one of the cooks that spoke to me were really nice as well.... Great to have a restaurant like this on Boyd's Creek. I would highly recommend eating here! I will definitely be going back. - Larry F

NJ Family.jpg

Real Deal Italian. Great food, friendly prompt servers. Don't forget about their Mexican menu either - best fajitas anywhere in Sevier County. These folks know what they are doing. - R Perdue

Love this restaurant! The food is excellent and a huge variety of items so everybody can find something they like, Their Mexican menu is great too. The owner is so nice. Always out at tables asking if everything is good. Makes you feel so welcome! Reasonable prices. Great lunch menu! 

- K Spruill


Cassie R - Enjoying some Garlic Knots and Homemade Marinara - Delicious!

Wonderful Family all the way from New Jersey enjoying dinner in our party room.  They said the food was "Excellent"

Amazing couldn't even come close to describing this place. Food is better than my full blooded Italian grandmother's food which says alot. Unbelievable definitely one of the best restaurants in East Tennessee hands down. Real food is the best food. Sorry not sorry chain restaurants. Mamma Mias has you beat by a long shot.  - L Cole

WS Group.jpg

WS Packaging  Coworkers and  our families stopped in to enjoy dinner in the party room.  Dinner was absolutely  amazing.  Service was top notch (thanks Liz).  Thanks to Paul, Nick and Mamma Naum for stopping in frequently to check on us.  So very personable.  Makes you feel like family and at home eating dinner.  Highly recommend  Mamma Mia Italian!

Mamma Mia’s Italian Restaurant is so much more than it appears!! Absolutely delicious cuisine, friendly staff, cozy atmosphere. The Shrimp Alfredo rivals dishes I’ve had in high end restaurants, and certainly outdoes any chain restaurant such as Olive Garden. The garlic knots are to die for and are served with their house made Marinara sauce! I did not try the cheesecake, but it looked absolutely delicious!! I will be back soon, and I am bringing friends. Please go try this restaurant at your earliest convenience (hint...they do takeout AND free delivery within a 7 mile radius too!!). Run, don’t walk!! Outrageously amazing Italian food awaits you!!!  - H R. Hale


Always nothing short of amazing food, top tier service, nice portions, and an all around home feeling. Nick and Paul always make their rounds of the dining roomand chat with all of the customers and really go out of their way to make sure your experience is nothing short of excellent. Definitely hands down THE BEST Italian restaurant around and we always know where we can go to get our fill of Italian cuisine! Keep up the excellent work guys!!! - S Morris

After ordering a delivery, not knowing their driver wasnt there until about 10 mins after order, but I was definitely willing to wait because I'm 5 months pregnant and was craving their chicken Alfredo sooo bad!, Mr Paul walked it over to my house at the beginning of the stables across the street! on one of the hottest days of the year!! I couldnt walk to get it because my daughter was taking a nap, but it was a total surprise to see him at my door! THANK YOU SO MUCH PAUL! YOU ARE AWESOME!! - T Hurd

bottom of page